Sustainable Building Sourcebook
Chapter: Water
 
Composting Toilets, Graywater Reuse
 
CSI Numbers: 15414 Composting Toilet Systems
 
Introduction:
 

There are several types of composting toilets, all based on the goal of water conservation. Waterless and forced-air composting toilets produce a valuable fertilizer. Electric toilets burn the waste. Some models use a very small amount of water or a chemical foam to assist the passage of waste to the composting chamber. When properly installed, none of them create odor or health problems.

 
At-A-Glance Notes:
 
Technology:
The technology for composting toilets is well developed. Newer models that offer complete self-contained wastewater integration with graywater systems are now available.
 
Suppliers:
Local off-the-shelf availability is limited.
 
Cost:
Composting toilets are cost-competitive with many septic systems. However, they are not cost-competitive with centralized wastewater systems, particularly in Austin, where sewage sludge is composted.
 
Public Acceptance:
There is limited appeal for composting toilets. Maintenance requirements vary by manufacturers, and although minor for many systems, they may prevent wider interest. People are typically interested in composting toilets when they do not have other satisfactory toilet options (e.g. lack of space for a septic field, impossibility of using heavy equipment on a site).
 
Regulatory:
Ordinances #880310-H and 880310-I address composting toilets and are a part of Chapters 6-10 of the Austin City Code. The Austin-Travis County Health Department (ATCHD) must issue a permit to install such toilets. Cost of the permit depends on whether the unit is National Sanitation Foundation (NSF)-approved or an engineered unit. A composting toilet is considered an alternative system and must be inspected annually by the ATCHD for a fee. Other municipalities may have other requirements for permits, inspections, and fees. Percolation tests do not apply if a sewer is present.
 
Considerations:
 

Composting toilets are lawful in Austin provided the units are approved by the National Sanitation Foundation [NSF] or engineered by a registered PE.

Austin presently composts sewage waste derived from its central wastewater system. The composted product is marketed as a landscape fertilizer called "Dillo Dirt". For this reason, it may be difficult to justify the extra cost and maintenance needs of a composting toilet in order to gain compost when a city sewer line is available. Additionally, the low volume of water required for standard toilets [1.6 GPF] makes the water savings from composting toilets quite low.

If a home does not have central wastewater services, a composting toilet may be practical. Coupled with a sub-surface graywater irrigation system (see Graywater Systems), installing a composting toilet can alleviate the need for a blackwater septic system; however, current state law prohibits water from toilets to be considered graywater. Always check state and local regulations before deciding on depending solely upon such a system.

There are commercial products available that range in cost depending on their complexity.

In areas where these systems can supplant large investments in septic systems, they are cost-competitive.

 
Guidelines:
 

There are two types of composting toilets: self-contained and split units.

Self-contained units combine the commode and the composting compartment in a single unit.

Split units have separate commode and composting components. The composting component must be positioned below the commode section. Some designs may use a small amount of water or foam to flush the commode. The storage chamber must be accessible for compost removal. This is an important design consideration for homes that have a concrete slab floor or a flat site.

Just like standard toilets, composting toilets have a vent to exhaust gases and prevent odors from entering the living space. Many models are fan-assisted. Several manufacturers offer heaters to accelerate the decomposition process in cold weather. Solar-powered models are available.

Commercial composting toilets are available in a variety of sizes to serve different sized households.

Water, Fig. 1

Example of a split-unit batch-composting toilet (Ecotech Carousel model)
 
Resources:
 
Professional Assistance:

See "Engineers" in the Yellow Pages

Components/Materials/Systems:

(Check with the listed companies regarding NSF approval)

AlasCan of Minnesota, Inc.
P.O. Box 88
Clear Lake, MN 55319
(320) 743-2909
http://www.alascanofmn.com
Manufacturer

Biolet USA, Inc.
Water Conservation Systems
P.O. Box 592
San Benito, TX 78586
800-5-BIOLET
http://www.biolet.com
NSF approved

Bio-Recycler Co.
5308 Emerald Dr.
Sykesville, MD 21784
(410) 795-2607
Not NSF approved

Bio-Sun Systems, Inc.
Box 134A, RR #2
Millerton, PA 16936
(800) 847-8840
http://www.nota.com/bio-sun
Not NSF approved manufacturer

Clivus Multrum, Inc.
15 Union St.
Laurence, MA 01840
(800) 962-8447, (800) 4-CLIVUS
http://www.clivusmultrum.com
Manufacturer, NSF approved

EcoTech Carousel Composting Toilet
50 Beharrell St.
Concord, MA 01742
(978) 369-3951
http://www.ecological-engineering.com/ecotech
5 brands of composting toilets, $2 catalog

Eco-Wise
110 W. Elizabeth St.
Austin, TX 78704
(512) 326-4474
http://www.ecowise.com
Local retailer

The Home Place
Rt 1 Box 307
Johnson City, TX 78636
(830) 868-7077
Sun-Mar retailer, NSF approved

Jade Mountain Inc.
P.O. Box 4616
Boulder, CO 80306
(800) 442-1972
http://www.jademountain.com
Retailer

Sancor Industries Ltd.
140-30 Milner Ave.
Scarborough, Ontario, Canada, M1S 3R3.
(800) 387-5126
http://www.envirolet.com
Manufacturer, NSF approved

Sun-Mar Corporation
5035 North Service Rd. Unit C9-C10
Burlington, Ontario Canada L7L 5V2
(800) 461-2461, (905) 332-1314 (Canada)
http://www.sun-mar.com
Manufacturer, NSF approved

General Assistance:

Austin-Travis County Health Department
15 Waller St.
Austin, TX 78702
(512) 469-2015

The Humanure Handbook; A Guide to Composting Human Manure , Jenkins Publishing, 1995. (800) 689-3233
http://www.jenkinspublishing.com
198 pages, indexed. Basic composting principles related to the composting of human excrement, with an emphasis on single family, small scale, and inexpensive applications. Includes information on commercial and homemade composting toilets. $19.00.

National Small Flows Clearinghouse
West Virginia University
P.O. Box 6064
Morgantown, WV 26506-6064
(800) 624-8301
http://www.estd.wvu.edu/nsfc
Information, "Small Flows" newsletter

Texas Water Resources Institute
Texas A & M University
301 Scoates Hall
College Station, TX 77843-2118
(409) 845-1851
http://www.towtrc.tamu.edu
"On-Site Insight," free newsletter about on-site wastewater treatment